— · Makeup
MOQ and lead time are indicative — final terms are confirmed by RFQ.
Pricing is not published on the catalog. Submit an RFQ and our team will prepare a quotation with unit pricing for your order quantity.
4.6
305 reviews
Rating breakdown
Most-mentioned keywords
Why consumers buy
1+1 bundle value
Many reviewers explicitly cite the two-pen bundle and OliveYoung sale discounts as the main reason for purchase, often buying extras to share with family or friends.
Repeat/loyalty purchase
A large share of reviews are repurchases, with customers stating they 'only use lilybyred' eyeliners or have repurchased two to three times.
Influencer/social recommendation
Several buyers mention purchasing after seeing it recommended by YouTubers, K-drama contestants (e.g., Single's Inferno cast) or friends.
Reputation for long wear
Buyers purchased specifically because of its reputation online as a long-lasting, smudge-proof, waterproof liner, especially for oily eyelids or teary eyes.
Natural, buildable color options
The soft Ash Black/Ash Brown shades attracted buyers who wanted a natural look rather than harsh jet-black lines, appealing to beginners and mature users alike.
How they use it
Daily eye makeup step
Used as an everyday eyeliner step for winged or thin precision lines, often applied once in the morning and expected to last through a full workday.
Layered/guideline use
Skin concerns raised — and how the product addressed them
✓Most reviewers say the formula resists smudging even on oily lids, though a subset with very oily skin still report fading or transfer by end of day.
✓Many with naturally watery or sensitive eyes report the liner stays intact through tears and long wear, though a few still see smudging at the inner corners.
✓The vast majority report no irritation and even highlight it as safe for sensitive eyes, but at least one review noted an allergic reaction, signaling a low but real risk.
Sentiment breakdown
Share of analyzed reviews by overall sentiment.
Some use it as a light guideline before applying bolder black liner, or to draw under-eye 'fake lash' lines and fill in lash lines.
Shared between family/friends
Because of the 1+1 format, many buyers split the two pens between themselves and a mother, sister, or friend.
Used in hot/humid or high-tear conditions
Frequently used in summer, during exercise, or by people with naturally watery eyes, valued for resisting smudging in these conditions.
Stockpiling due to frequent sellouts
Several reviewers note the product often sells out at OliveYoung, prompting them to buy multiples when in stock.
✓Buildable application lets users adjust intensity, but some feel the color is inherently too light or inconsistent between batches, requiring extra layering.
✓Not resolved for a portion of users — several report the tip or ink drying out prematurely, shortening usable product life despite the 1+1 format.
Concerns and outcomes summarized from reviews; percentages are approximate.
