— · Makeup
MOQ and lead time are indicative — final terms are confirmed by RFQ.
Pricing is not published on the catalog. Submit an RFQ and our team will prepare a quotation with unit pricing for your order quantity.
4.7
288 reviews
Rating breakdown
Most-mentioned keywords
Why consumers buy
Repurchase / brand loyalty
Many reviewers explicitly state this is their 2nd, 3rd, or 5th+ repurchase, citing consistent quality and habit as their main reason for buying again.
Influencer/word-of-mouth recommendation
Several buyers mention discovering the product via YouTube reviews or friends' recommendations and buying based on hype around long-wear claims.
Affordable price / good value
Multiple reviews cite low price, discount periods, or 'good value for money' as a key reason for trying or restocking the product.
Slim, precise tip design
Buyers specifically chose this over other eyeliners because of its unusually thin barrel, which they say is ideal for tightlining and detailed lower-lash work.
Comparison shopping vs other K-beauty gel liners
Reviewers frequently compare it favorably to Canmake, Clio, and other gel liners, choosing lilybyred for its balance of smoothness and staying power.
How they use it
Lower lash line / waterline application
The most frequently cited use case is lining the lower eyelid or mucosal/waterline for a soft, enlarging eye effect.
Tightlining and detail work
Skin concerns raised — and how the product addressed them
✓Many reviewers with oily lids report the gel formula holds up better than competitors, though a minority still experience smudging or panda-eye by end of day.
✓Several reviewers note the formula applies without stinging or discomfort even on sensitive eye areas, calling it gentle for tightlining.
✓Reviewers with monolids specifically praise the slim tip for making application easier and more precise than bulkier liners.
Points to note
Sentiment breakdown
Share of analyzed reviews by overall sentiment.
Its slim tip is used for precise tightlining and small detailed lines, particularly by users with monolids or oily lids.
Daily/everyday makeup routine
Reviewers describe using it as a daily driver eyeliner, often as one step layered under or with eyeshadow for a natural look.
Dual-purpose as lip liner
Multiple reviewers repurpose the pencil as a lip liner, especially with natural-toned lipsticks, citing similar smudge-resistance.
Layering with setting products
Some users layer a setting spray, fixer, or powder over the liner to extend wear time when they notice fading or smudging by midday.
✓A Korean reviewer with watery, oily eyes states this outperformed multiple premium brands that smudged or wiped off on them.
✓Not fully solved — several reviewers report the pencil core snapping or breaking, though some mitigate it by advancing the lead gradually.
Concerns and outcomes summarized from reviews; percentages are approximate.
